April 22, 2004
Reviews

One of the many things that I am doing today at work is writing my annual review. Yep, you read that right. I'M writing MY review. The way it works around here is you have to write your own review, turn it in to your boss, he writes his review of you and then you both get together in a room and compare notes. It can be brutal.

I will also say that I am personally four-square against annual reviews. I feel that if I am doing a good job, I should be told throughout the year, like when it happens. Conversely, if I'm doing something I oughtn't, I'd like to know when it happens so that I don't keep on doing it. Surprises at review time suck!

Ugh! I hate doing this!

Posted by Buzz at April 22, 2004 12:33 PM
Comments

*jumps up to look over cubicle* When did you start working here?

Posted by: Genuine at April 22, 2004 12:48 PM

I'm SO with you on this one. I'm having a go-around with my boss now, and it may come home to roost on my annual evaluation. It's something that easily could have been taken care of in a couple of meetings.

Posted by: TW at April 22, 2004 12:49 PM

They once wanted me to write my own job description here... So I wrote "Sit and look pretty".

In retrospect I should have added "blog" and "shop for housewares on the internet", but I was drunk with power and I totally forgot.

Posted by: Jennifer at April 22, 2004 12:52 PM

I so agree with Buzz's assessment of 'guidance when needed'. Early in my career, I had a new manager (we'll call him Bob) who put on my review that I sometimes came in late. After discussing this with Bob for a while, I realized that I came in late on the days after Bob told me he needed something on "his desk first thing in the morning." I'd stay at work till 1 or 2 in the morning finishing up the item(s), and then roll in late by 10 minutes (only 6 or 7 hours after I'd left.) Since Bob's manager had seen the draft review, Bob decided he wasn't going to change the review. I worked for Bob for exactly 6 months, and then moved on. Like many people, he was good technically, but I don't think he had the best people skills ! So how come HE had the bad people skills, but I ended up suffering for it ?

Posted by: Willie's Buddy Jimmy at April 22, 2004 01:33 PM

I love the skin and the content is consistently well written. You need to pick up the pace on some days. All in all, I'll give you a 4.5 out of 5. There's no money in the budget though, so you will have to get by on my lame comments. Now get back to work.

Posted by: JJJB at April 22, 2004 01:35 PM

Gosh!!! Don't like those reviews either. Some of my links on da-latest post might help ya... They he'ped me! Chin-UP! I love the new clothes your blog is wearing. I should have told ya that before now... oops!

Posted by: Sallie at April 22, 2004 02:03 PM

in my office we write our own review and the boss looks it over and decides if he/she agrees with it or not. they don't even write one for us themselves! the last few years i've taken to giving them a HUGE novel for a performance review, outlining in painful detail all the things i've done. that way, even if they cut stuff out, it's still better then anything they would have written about me. besides, since i'm having to do it on company time, they're paying me to write it!

Posted by: P at April 22, 2004 02:08 PM

I'm with ya on this one, I hate them too. I as well have to write my own reviews and I feel it's tougher that way. I hat evaluating myself.

Posted by: Mike at April 22, 2004 02:08 PM

We have to do self-assessments every year, but usually, they go along with raises. Therefore, I don't mind. Also, it is a chance to toot my own horn and have it put in my folder (and bring it along if I have interviews!)

Oh, and I have had the same boss for forever, and we usually just sit there and talk about something other than work the whole time because my performance is never an issue. Yay!

Posted by: Adelle at April 22, 2004 02:14 PM

The key is having the secretary go into the bosses office to steal his evaluation, so you'll have the same answers. "I got the same thing for number six also, wow do WE think alike!"

Posted by: Lee at April 22, 2004 02:35 PM

Oh...just one more benefit of being self employed. I pat myself on the back all day long.

"My, my, my Kathy Howe, what a stellar job you are doing AGAIN. Thank you for being part of this team."

*grins*

Posted by: Kathy Howe at April 22, 2004 03:05 PM

I have ALWAYS written my own reviews. Grrrrrrrrr.

Posted by: Mindy at April 22, 2004 05:49 PM

It's the same way where I work. We almost had quarterly reviews but mgmt was too lazy to cope with them.

Posted by: Lisa at April 22, 2004 11:05 PM

my last job worked the same way -- plus it was a non-profit organization, so it was all touchy-feely and stuff. very annoying when it came time to performance reviews. "i feel that..." blah blah blah. Enough already. It's not the clients that make social work a difficult field to work in, it's the co-workers!

Posted by: no name yet at April 23, 2004 06:53 AM

When I was contract I had to write mine up and give it to my boss and he would either agree or disagree. Now that I'm hired in full time, they write and I tell them what I think. I like that much better. Much less work for me and besides I hate talking about myself. I know hard to tell.

Posted by: Tom at April 23, 2004 10:40 AM

I just did my portion of mine this morning ... I am waiting for the meeting with the boss. Last year, they went to great lengths to explain that the annual review process is NOT tied to the raise process. I then asked the stupid question, "Ok, then what IS tied to the raise process? Lottery? Blackmail? Alphabetical? I'm still waiting for an answer." I do remember one time years and years ago I actually talked my boss out of adding a bad comment to my review. I made him understand that if he never told me to do this task he was angry about, how could he hold it against me that I didn't psychically KNOW he wanted it done. Ah ... the fun!

Posted by: Lisa at April 26, 2004 05:52 PM
My wish list.

www.flickr.com
This is a Flickr badge showing public photos from buzzstuff. Make your own badge here.








Google






-d: How do you feel about being Governor of Indiana? [Buzz it]

keith: Bill said it all before I could get here.... [Buzz it]

geeky: Buzz For President in '08! [Buzz it]

cassie-b: I noticed that last weekend went Waaaay too fast. [Buzz it]

Bill : Congress has already passed provisions like this - [Buzz it]

Global Warming, my ass!
NSST
Sunday morning thoughts
ECF™ - Been a long time
Re: Daylight Saving Time









Powered by
The Indescribably Delicious
Movable Type 2.63
---------------
Hosted by
The Great and Powerful
Blogomania
---------------


Designs & Skinning:
Got Moxie?



eXTReMe Tracker